Worked example
Start with Rent per month now of $2,200, Rent growth per year of 3%, Purchase price of $420,000, Down payment of $42,000, Closing costs of $8,000, Mortgage rate of 6.5%, Tax, insurance, and upkeep per year of $7,000, Home price growth per year of 3%, and 7 years you would stay. Owning ahead of renting, after equity is $77,368. The breakdown is Rent paid over the stay of $202,289, Cash into owning of $299,694, Equity credited of $174,774, and Owning, net of that equity of $124,921. A 30-year fixed loan is assumed. Selling costs and taxes on a sale are not taken out of equity. A negative headline means renting spent less.
How this number is made
Renting and buying spend cash on different schedules. This comparison adds the rent you would pay, and it adds the cash of owning minus a credit for equity at the end. It is not a forecast.
- Use a stay long enough that selling costs would not erase the comparison. They are not deducted here.
- Owner costs are tax, insurance, and a maintenance reserve. Principal and interest are calculated.
Formula
Rent cost grows each year. Owner cash = down + closing + mortgage payments + owner costs × years. Equity credit = appreciated price − remaining loan. Net owning cost = owner cash − equity credit.
Questions
Where are repairs and selling costs?
Repairs belong in the yearly owner figure if you want them. Selling costs are not subtracted from the equity credit. A short stay looks better here than it will at a closing table.
Does this include the tax deduction?
No. Mortgage interest may or may not beat the standard deduction. That depends on the rest of your return.